Home	Forums	What's new	Resources

"Obsolete" games legal to download?

Alexvrb - Oct 31, 2003

		Alexvrb		Oct 31, 2003
			http://www.gamepro.com/gamepro/domestic/ga...ews/3... Here's a bit of the article: The Library of Congress has recently granted copyright exemptions in the Digital Millenium Act to obsolete games. The exemption applies to games that require the original hardware as a condition of access, and if the game is âno longer manufactured or reasonably available in the commercial marketplace.â�

		mal		Nov 1, 2003
			I think to say that obsolete games are legal to download is a bit of a stretch. I was under the impression that this just allows people to circumvent copy protection on computer software protected by dongles which are obsolete or that don't work and computer software copy-protected by a media that is obsolete (including old games). As far as I can tell, this means that you still have to own them, but you wouldn't be prosecuted under the DMCA if you were to get around the copy protection to continue to use them. I'll move this to general for now, unless someone can back up this 'free to download' line and it will go to news. I read up on this at The Register....

		ExCyber		Nov 1, 2003
			mal pretty much has it. The exemption is not for copyright in general, just Sec. 1201 anticircumvention rules. Copyrights are still perpetual in the US until Congress decides to get out of bed with big media. See, the Supreme Court ruled that even though the Constitution says that copyrights must be for a limited time, it's legal for Congress to keep extending them forever as long as there's a chance they'll decide not to next time.

		antime		Nov 1, 2003
			There's been a lot of people posting this rubbish on Usenet and message boards, but you'd think that a print magazine would do even rudimentary fact-checking.. I predict this will be the new "24h rule".

		aaron		Nov 1, 2003
			mal totally said "dongles"

		mal		Nov 1, 2003
			Worse than that, I was talking about things protected by dongles.